COMMENTS ON THE ISSUE
What Do You Think of CBC High
School's New Drug Testing Policy?
Tianay Pulphus; Jennings High School,
2009
Many people will
say "this is infringing on our rights!" My thing is, if you have
nothing to hide, then there really isn't a problem. It is just a
piece of hair!!! True it does end up being a big deal if you are
doing these drugs, but the thing is you shouldn't. This is just
a way to try and prevent that from happening. If it is that much
of a problem for the school to have to resort to such drastic
measures to get YOU (their students) to stop abusing themselves
and messing up there future then so be it. If you have a problem
with this then it really goes to show exactly how ignorant to
the fact that there are those that are helping you.
Patty
Rodriguez; Parkway North High School; 2009
I don't think I agree with the $45
part. That's kind of rude to say, "Hey, you HAVE to do this to
make US happy, but you have to pay." I don't know, seems kind of
rude to me. Anywho, doesn't marijuana stay in your hair for
seven years?
Elizabeth Kiderlin; Former Director, St. Louis
World Affairs Council
These tests in my opinion primarily serve to
desensitize the next generation to invasions of their privacy.
They are growing up in an atmosphere of "suspected until proven
innocent". As a result, they become complacent about their
individual rights. Some uber drug testing equipment salesman is
making their fortune over this.
Corey Wischmeyer; Metro High
School, 2006
Listen,
CBC is a private school; they have standards they wish to keep;
they should be able to keep them.
Tony Keel; S.L.U.H., 2006
I completely agree with this drug
testing policy. I mean, I had to get such a test for my job, and
I bet some other people do as well. It's no big deal, and the
school is very generous in not expelling the kids at first. I
like their rehab idea. However, the parents have to pay for it,
so that will cause some issues. That's what private schools do.
Good thing the test doesn't pick up alcohol, because I don't
want to know all the people that do that.
Sarah O'Brien; Incarnate Word
Academy, 2006
The Drug
Testing Policy at CBC might be one of the largest infringements
on student rights that is happening in local STL--besides normal
newspaper editing (censorship?) and the favoritism shown to
athletes. The tough part about this event is the fact that CBC
is a private school, and is not funded singularly by the
government (they help, but not much). Since it is a private
school, the boys have many other options, even parochial schools
to attend that receive archdiocesan funding, therefore if they
wanted to protest the drug test, the administration would have
the power to say, "Have a problem? Go somewhere else." Another
fact is that this isn't happening only at CBC. If a student who
attends a private high school gets in trouble with the police,
or is found with drugs or alcohol on their person the school can
ask them to leave. This is usually done under the idea that by
removing that student, they are reinforcing that they have a
good reputation. IE--if you damage the reputation of a private
high school you can "lawfully" be asked to withdraw. Not that we
actually have the right, as citizens or as teenagers. But this
sort of activity against students and their private lives is not
fair, and some measure needs to be taken to check these private
educational organizations so that they are within the
constitution.